Valentina Trustees charge over Far North pā site damage dismissed
An Environment Court judge has dismissed a prosecution against Valentina Trustees regarding damage to an ancient pā site in New Zealand's Far North. The case failed because Heritage New Zealand could not provide sufficient evidence regarding the specific instructions given to the contractors who performed the earthworks.
Why it matters
The ruling highlights the legal challenges in holding property owners accountable for archaeological damage when contractor communication is opaque.
The archaeological damage was obvious. The culprit was not.
In a stinging ruling, an Environment Court judge has dismissed a prosecution over earthworks at an ancient Far North pā site, finding that critical gaps left a fundamental question unanswered.
That missing piece sank Heritage New Zealand's case against Valentina Trustees, with Environment Court Judge Jeff Smith dismissing a charge over earthworks that damaged culturally significant sites in the Far North.
Valentina Trustees was charged over alleged damage to six archaeological sites on its property at Takarau Bay in the Far North.
The 70ha block stretches from the Hihi Peninsula to west of Taemaro and contains the spiritually significant Puketakahia Pā kāinga (home) site on Maunga Whakaangi.
At the judge-alone trial in October, Heritage NZ had to prove that the company knew or ought reasonably to have suspected that the sites contained archaeological features.
Get smarter about the news
Sign up free for a feed built around what you actually care about, Dive Deeper research on any story, and the full text of every article.
Create free accountAlready have an account? Sign in