US seized California island ranch after $4m offer; jury awarded family $12.7m
A federal jury awarded a California family $12.7 million for their land on Santa Cruz Island after the government seized it via eminent domain. The verdict significantly exceeded the government's initial $4 million valuation, concluding a long-standing property dispute.
Why it matters
Highlights the legal complexities and financial outcomes of eminent domain cases involving private property and federal conservation efforts.
A federal jury in Los Angeles ordered the United States government to pay $12.7 million (£7.8 million) to a California family after it seized their 6,300-acre ranch on Santa Cruz Island. The verdict, delivered in February 1999 after a three-week trial, ended a decades-long property dispute between federal park officials and attorney Francis Gherini, whose family had owned part of the island for more than a century. According to contemporary reporting by the Los Angeles Times, the jury spent about five hours deliberating before rejecting the government's long-standing valuation of the property. The US government had initially offered $4 million for Gherini's share of the island before using eminent domain to seize the land in 1996.
Get smarter about the news
Sign up free for a feed built around what you actually care about, Dive Deeper research on any story, and the full text of every article.
Create free accountAlready have an account? Sign in