Study Finds Heated Asteroids Lost Chlorine; Pristine Meteorites May Overstate Halogen Supply

A new study published in Icarus suggests that heating within asteroids caused them to lose significant amounts of halogens like chlorine and fluorine. This finding implies that current models based on pristine meteorites may overestimate the volatile inventory available to early rocky planets.
Why it matters
Understanding the chemical composition of early planetary building blocks is essential for accurately modeling the formation and volatile history of Earth.
The meteorites that look most pristine may be giving planetary scientists an overly generous count of the fluorine, chlorine, bromine and iodine that fed the rocky planets, according to a journal pre-proof listed as available online Nov. 14, 2026, in Icarus. Anthony Gargano and seven co-authors report that heating inside asteroids drove off and redistributed these halogens, so the bulk halogen budgets of the parent bodies could be much lower than their least-altered meteorites imply.Earth's volatile inventory is judged against meteorites, so an inflated meteorite baseline changes how much volatile loss scientists must explain. The authors propose that parent-body processing could help reconcile chondrite-based accretion models with Earth's lower volatile inventory.The paper, "Halogen and K-Cl isotope records in non-carbonaceous chondrites: evolution of the volatile element inventory of asteroidal accretionary feedstock," lists Gargano, Zoltan Vaci, Justin I.
Get smarter about the news
Sign up free for a feed built around what you actually care about, Dive Deeper research on any story, and the full text of every article.
Create free accountAlready have an account? Sign in