Rose Niven, wins Supreme Court appeal, has sentence reduced

The New Zealand Supreme Court has reduced the prison sentence of Jessica Mulford, who was convicted for the fatal abuse of a toddler. The court ruled that her age at the time of the initial offense was not adequately considered during the original sentencing.
Why it matters
The ruling highlights judicial debates regarding the consideration of youth and maturity in sentencing for violent crimes.
Jessica Mulford claims Harlee-Rose Niven was injured after falling out of a window at Dylan Berry’s parents’ property at Pongokawa, Bay of Plenty, in April 2022. Composite photo / NZME
A teenage stepmother who inflicted fatal abdominal injuries on a toddler has had her sentence reduced by almost 30% by the Supreme Court.
Jessica Lee Rose Mulford’s actions left 2-year-old Harlee-Rose Niven’s pancreas split in two, after an earlier strangulation incident involving the girl five months before her death.
In February 2025, Justice Neil Campbell jailed Mulford, then 20, for five years and seven months when she appeared in the High Court at Hamilton.
Mulford’s subsequent appeal against her sentence reached the Supreme Court last year .
Despite earlier appeal failures, the Supreme Court has now found, in a decision released today, that Mulford’s age at the time of the strangulation offence, 17, should have been taken into account.
Also covering this story
One other newsroom covered this event. We read that version too.
Get smarter about the news
Sign up free for a feed built around what you actually care about, Dive Deeper research on any story, and the full text of every article.
Create free accountAlready have an account? Sign in