'Prime Minister's Nominee Can't Be Expected To Defy Him': Justice Datta Doubts Independence Of Election Commissioners' Selection Panel
Supreme Court Justice Dipankar Datta questioned the independence of the selection committee for India's Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners under the 2023 law. He argued that a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister cannot be expected to act as an independent check on the Prime Minister in the selection process.
Why it matters
This judicial observation raises critical concerns about the impartiality and perceived independence of India's Election Commission, which is vital for ensuring free and fair democratic elections. The outcome of this legal challenge could significantly impact the integrity and public trust in India's electoral system.
Supreme Court justice Dipankar Datta today prima facie questioned the neutrality of the mechanism for appointing the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners under the 2023 law, observing that the Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister cannot be expected to oppose the Prime Minister in the selection process.Justice Datta prima facie observed that the Prime Minister-nominated Cabinet Minister could not be expected to act as an independent counterweight to the Prime Minister.“The Minister nominated by the Prime Minister, to function as the third member on the Selection Committee chaired by the Prime Minister, cannot be expected to defy his own nominator and risk his continuation as such nominated member on the committee, for all practical purposes,” he observed.Justice Dipankar Datta delivered his opinion on whether the challenge to the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 should be…
Get smarter about the news
Sign up free for a feed built around what you actually care about, Dive Deeper research on any story, and the full text of every article.
Create free accountAlready have an account? Sign in