Mathematicians Are Like Luddites
This essay explores the etymological and historical connections between weaving, technology, and the Luddite movement. It argues that mathematicians and modern tech workers share a similar relationship with automation as the original weavers.
Why it matters
It provides a philosophical perspective on the history of labor and automation, framing current technological shifts within a long-standing human tradition of craft.
Mathematicians are like Luddites. Yes, the actual weavers, not just the slur against people who are against technology. They were weavers in general: weavers, knitters, and cloth finishers defending the value of their skill and lifestyle.
Maybe astrology for men , but just as fun.
The Proto-Indo European root tek-/ tekō/*tek/: to plait/to weave.
Context: that which is woven together (con-*).
Textile . Subtle: the underlying (sub) thread.
Subtext . not etymologically a duplicate of “subtle” but sure feels like one.
Technology: from the word tekne, which means “craft”. Weaving is an old craft, about 20,000 years old. Flint knapping and fire making are older, and damned hard, but weaving has a combination of freedom and skill.
We talk about ideas as though we were handling fabric because, for a very long time, making fabric was one of our most sophisticated skills .
Get smarter about the news
Sign up free for a feed built around what you actually care about, Dive Deeper research on any story, and the full text of every article.
Create free accountAlready have an account? Sign in