Justice Karnan’s incident brought judicial misconduct to the forefront

The article reflects on the 2017 controversy surrounding former High Court judge C.S. Karnan, who was sentenced to prison for criminal contempt after issuing orders against Supreme Court judges. It highlights the internal judicial crisis and the debate over whether to punish a sitting judge or allow him to retire to preserve the institution's image.
Why it matters
It serves as a historical case study on judicial accountability and the challenges of maintaining institutional integrity when a member of the judiciary engages in misconduct.
NEW DELHI The ‘Justice Karnan episode’, as a few retired judges reminisce, saw a tense judiciary at crossroads nearly a decade ago in the early months of 2017. C.S. Karnan, controversial former High Court judge, passes away in Chennai C.S. Karnan, controversial former High Court judge, passes away in Chennai He was sentenced to six months of imprisonment during his stint as a judge of Calcutta High Court in 2017 after he passed an “order” sentencing the then CJI and seven other Supreme Court judges to five years of imprisonment C.S. Karnan, controversial former High Court judge, passes away in Chennai storyline 1 The public utterances of Calcutta High Court judge, Justice C. S. Karnan, who died on November 13, had turned “the judiciary into a laughing stock”.
Get smarter about the news
Sign up free for a feed built around what you actually care about, Dive Deeper research on any story, and the full text of every article.
Create free accountAlready have an account? Sign in