Here's Why The Dire Wolf Really Wasn't Brought Back From Extinction, Scientists Argue

Scientists argue that biotech efforts to recreate extinct species, such as the dire wolf, are scientifically inaccurate and should not be labeled as 'de-extinction.' They propose the term 'lineage-genome conflation' to describe the process of editing existing species to resemble extinct ones.
Why it matters
This debate highlights the ethical and scientific limitations of genetic engineering in conservation and the potential for misleading public perception regarding biodiversity.
When is a de-extinction not a de-extinction? Some headline-grabbing methods for bringing extinct species back to life fall short of such grand claims, according to a new argument published in Biology Letters .
The case is put forward by marine biologist Andrew Davinack and biochemist Charlotte Daniels from Wheaton College Massachusetts, with much of their attention focused on the so-called 'de-extinction' of the dire wolf by biotech company Colossal Biosciences in 2025.
What Colossal Biosciences did was make genetic edits to grey wolf cells in order to breed animals with characteristics that more closely resembled dire wolves – including larger bodies, bigger teeth, and paler coats of fur.
That's actually not a de-extinction, Davinack and Daniels contest, and they've got a new term for the mistake of calling it one: lineage-genome conflation.
Get smarter about the news
Sign up free for a feed built around what you actually care about, Dive Deeper research on any story, and the full text of every article.
Create free accountAlready have an account? Sign in