'AI' Is Not a Tool by Rich Hickey
Software developer Rich Hickey argues that Large Language Models (LLMs) do not qualify as tools because they lack the predictability, control, and sensory feedback inherent in traditional implements. He posits that true tools require human expertise and agency, whereas LLMs operate autonomously in ways that distance the user from the task.
Why it matters
This philosophical critique challenges the prevailing industry narrative that AI is merely a productivity tool, suggesting a fundamental shift in how humans interact with technology.
(I keep delivering this as a quip, here's a bit more)
First order of business - is ' tool ' going to have an interesting, distinguishing and thus illuminative meaning or be a mere platitudinous stand-in for "anything useful"?
We'll save tool as "anyone/thing that can be exploited" for the AI titans, for whom VCs, politicians, wannabe-titan-CEOs, software devs, rural towns etc are all 'tools'. The pockets on the front of my shirts are useful (I need to keep my reading glasses handy), but they are not tools. Similarly, fast food drive-thru windows are useful, but are not tools (more later).
a device or implement, especially one held in the hand, used to carry out a particular function an instrument (such as a hammer or saw) used or worked by hand : an instrument used by a handicraftsperson or laborer in their work
Get smarter about the news
Sign up free for a feed built around what you actually care about, Dive Deeper research on any story, and the full text of every article.
Create free accountAlready have an account? Sign in